Our Menu
Small-batch cookies, cupcakes, custom cakes and cake pops, made to order
Cookies
Decorated Cut-Out Sugar Cookies
Hand-decorated with egg-free glaze icing. Perfect for any occasion - weddings, birthdays, holidays, corporate events.
Iced with: Glossy glaze icing (smooth, colorful, sets beautifully)
$36 per baker's dozen (13)
Best enjoyed within 2-3 week
Brown-Butter Chocolate Chip
Our signature cookie - nutty brown-butter depth with premium semi-sweet chocolate chips. An elevated classic.
$24 per baker's dozen
Best enjoyed within 1-2 week
Classic Chocolate Chip
Soft, buttery, timeless favorite — the cookie that builds loyalty.
$24 per baker's dozen
Best enjoyed within 1-2 week
Lemon Lavender Shortbread
Elegant, melt-in-your-mouth shortbread with bright lemon zest and subtle culinary lavender. Premium gift-worthy treat.
$24 per baker's dozen
Best enjoyed within 3-4 week
Snickerdoodles
Soft cinnamon-sugar cookies with a tender crumb. Nostalgic and comforting.
$24 per baker's dozen
Best enjoyed within 1-2 week
Oatmeal Cranberry
Hearty oats with sweet-tart dried cranberries. A healthier indulgence.
$24 per baker's dozen
Best enjoyed within 1-2 week
Peanut Butter Blossom
Classic peanut butter cookie with Hershey's Kiss center. A beloved favorite.
$24 per baker's dozen
Best enjoyed within 1-2 week
Holiday Gingerbread Cookies
Spiced gingerbread cutouts; can be decorated with icing or left plain. Perfect for holiday celebrations.
$24 plain / $36 decorated per baker's dozen
✓ Seasonal Oct-Dec • 2-3 week shelf life
Italian Pizzelles
Traditional Italian waffle cookies - delicate, crisp, flavored with anise or vanilla. A Northeast Ohio heritage favorite.
$8 per dozen
Best enjoyed within 3-4 week
Cupcakes
Classic Vanilla
Fluffy vanilla cupcakes with smooth American buttercream frosting. Simple perfection.
$2.00 each • $24 per dozen
Best enjoyed within 2-3 day
Double Chocolate
Rich chocolate cake with chocolate buttercream. For true chocolate lovers.
$2.00 each • $24 per dozen
Best enjoyed within 2-3 day
Elysian Lemon Lavender
Delicate lemon cake with subtle lavender notes, topped with lemon buttercream. Our signature flavor.
$2.50 each • $30 per dozen (filled)
Best enjoyed within 2-3 day
Custom Cakes
All celebration cakes are custom-made to order. Visit our Custom Cakes page for full details, pricing, and our interactive cake builder.
Flavors Available
- ✓ Classic Vanilla
- ✓ Rich Chocolate
- ✓ Lemon (zest & extract)
- ✓ Strawberry (freeze-dried powder)
- ✓ Red Velvet
- ✓ Funfetti
- ✓ Carrot Cake
- ✓ Almond
- ✓ Spice Cake (seasonal)
Frosting & Finishes
Iced with: silky American buttercream (or our bakery-style buttercream for outdoor events)
Fillings: Buttercream, jam/preserves, chocolate chips, cookie crumbs, Nutella, Biscoff spread
Finishes: Buttercream (smooth or piped), fondant, candy melt drip, modeling chocolate
Cupcake sizes: Mini $1.00 (2-dozen min) · Standard $2.00 · Filled $2.50 · Jumbo $3.00
Cake Pops
Bite-sized bliss on a stick! Perfect for parties, gifts, and grab-and-go treats.
Classic Vanilla
Vanilla cake + vanilla buttercream, dipped in white or pastel candy melts, topped with sprinkles.
$2.75 each • $16 per 6-pack
Best enjoyed within 3-5 day
Chocolate Fudge
Rich chocolate cake + chocolate buttercream, dipped in dark or milk chocolate coating.
$2.75 each • $16 per 6-pack
Best enjoyed within 3-5 day
Strawberry
Vanilla cake with freeze-dried strawberry powder + strawberry buttercream, dipped in pink candy melts.
$2.75 each • $16 per 6-pack
Best enjoyed within 3-5 day
Cookies & Cream
Vanilla cake + crushed Oreos + buttercream, dipped in white chocolate, drizzled with dark chocolate.
$2.75 each • $16 per 6-pack
Best enjoyed within 3-5 day
Peanut Butter Cup
Chocolate cake + peanut butter buttercream, dipped in milk chocolate, drizzled with PB candy melts.
$2.75 each • $16 per 6-pack
Best enjoyed within 3-5 day
Holiday Peppermint Mocha
Chocolate cake + peppermint buttercream, dipped in dark chocolate, topped with crushed candy cane.
$2.75 each • $16 per 6-pack
✓ Seasonal Nov-Dec • 3-5 day shelf life
Perfect For: Party favors, gift boxes, grab-and-go treats, smart store vending
Each cake pop is individually wrapped and labeled with ingredients and allergens. Pricing: $2.75 each, $10 for 3-pack, $16 for 6-pack, $30 per dozen.
Muffins & Breads
Blueberry Muffins
Moist, tender muffins bursting with fresh blueberries. Breakfast perfection.
$12 per half dozen
Best enjoyed within 3-4 day
Banana Nut Muffins
Sweet banana muffins with crunchy walnuts. A classic favorite.
$12 per half dozen
Best enjoyed within 3-4 day
Banana Bread
Dense, moist banana bread. Perfect for breakfast or a snack.
$10 per loaf
Best enjoyed within 4-6 day
Seasonal & Gift Boxes
Fall Favorites (Sept-Nov)
- 🍂 Pumpkin Bread & Muffins
- 🍎 Apple Pie
- 🎃 Pumpkin Spice Cookies
- 🍁 Spice Cake
Available September through November
Holiday Treats (Nov-Dec)
- 🎄 Gingerbread Cookies
- ⭐ Holiday Decorated Cookies
- 🎁 Cookie Gift Boxes
- 🍬 Fudge & Peanut Brittle
Available November through December
Wedding Cookie Tables
Northeast Ohio tradition! We create beautiful cookie assortments for your special day. Includes 12-15 varieties, individually wrapped, custom quantities.
From $20/dozen (assorted, 10+ dozen)
Request QuoteCorporate Gift Boxes
Impress clients and employees with custom cookie assortments. Available year-round, custom branding available.
$35-60 per box
Inquire🌿 Why no cream cheese frosting?
We're a small home bakery, and Ohio's home-baking (cottage food) rules only allow treats that are safe at room temperature. Cream cheese frosting, custards and fresh cream fillings need refrigeration, so they're not on our menu.
The good news: our silky American buttercream and glossy glaze icing are made fresh for every order, and our customers say they don't miss a thing. More in our FAQ →